Why Can't My Partner Take Criticism? Understanding Defensive Behaviour

You give your partner gentle feedback:

  • "I felt hurt when you forgot our anniversary"
  • "Can we try a different approach to this?"
  • "That comment was hurtful"

Their response:

  • Immediate defensiveness
  • "Well, you always..."
  • Anger or withdrawal
  • A counterattack instead of listening

This is defensive behaviour.

If your partner consistently can't take criticism, it's not about you being too harsh. It's about their psychological defences.

This article explains why, and what you can actually do about it.

What Is Defensive Behaviour?

Defensive behaviour is when someone:

  1. Receives feedback or criticism
  2. Perceives it as a threat (to their self-image, competence, or relationship)
  3. Reacts with protection instead of openness:
    • Attacking back
    • Justifying/explaining
    • Withdrawing
    • Denying
    • Blaming you

Key insight: They're not trying to hurt you. Their ego feels threatened, so they're protecting it automatically.

Why Partners Get Defensive

Reason 1: Fragile Ego

Their self-image is sensitive to criticism. They interpret feedback as:

  • "You're not good enough"
  • "You're a bad partner"
  • "I don't love you"
  • "You're a failure"

A feedback about behaviour feels like a judgement about character.

Reason 2: Shame

Shame is the feeling that something is fundamentally wrong with you (vs. guilt, which is "I did something wrong").

If your partner operates from shame, criticism triggers shame, which triggers defence.

Reason 3: Past Experiences

If they were:

  • Criticised harshly in childhood
  • Shamed for mistakes
  • Never met expectations
  • In previous relationships with harsh criticism

They learnt that criticism = threat. Now they defend automatically.

Reason 4: Lack of Ego Awareness

They don't recognise their defensive reaction as it's happening. They genuinely believe they're just responding to your attack.

They might think:

  • "I'm not being defensive; you're being harsh"
  • "I'm just explaining myself"
  • "You're the problem, not me"

Reason 5: Low Tolerance for Discomfort

Hearing that they hurt you, made a mistake, or need to change is uncomfortable. Instead of sitting with that discomfort, they defend.

Common Defensive Responses

Defence 1: The Counterattack

You say: "I felt hurt when you didn't listen to me"

They say: "Well, you never listen to me either. You're always on your phone."

What's happening: Instead of addressing your feedback, they attack you to deflect.

Defence 2: Justification/Explanation

You say: "I felt hurt"

They say: "I didn't mean it that way. I was tired. You misunderstood what I said."

What's happening: They're explaining away your feelings instead of hearing them. They believe if they can justify their behaviour, they're off the hook.

Defence 3: Invalidation

You say: "That hurt me"

They say: "No, it didn't. You're too sensitive. That's not what I meant."

What's happening: They're denying your experience to protect themselves from guilt.

Defence 4: Withdrawal

You say: "I need to talk about something"

They say: Nothing. They leave, go silent, or change the subject.

What's happening: Instead of engaging with discomfort, they leave.

Defence 5: Blame-Shifting

You say: "I feel like you don't prioritise me"

They say: "That's not true. You're the one who's always busy. You don't prioritise me."

What's happening: They make it about you instead of hearing you.

The Damage of Defensive Behaviour in Relationships

1. You Stop Sharing Feedback

If you know they'll get defensive, you stop trying. You stop communicating, which means problems don't get solved.

2. Resentment Builds

You feel unheard. They feel attacked. Both of you feel misunderstood.

3. Intimacy Decreases

You can't be vulnerable if you know they'll get defensive. Real intimacy requires being able to share feedback without fear.

4. The Same Conflicts Repeat

Because nothing gets resolved, you have the same arguments over and over.

5. You Start Walking on Eggshells

You become hyper-aware of how they might react. You self-censor. You lose authenticity.

What NOT to Do

Don't Attack Back

If they get defensive and you counter-attack, you both become defensive. The cycle continues.

Don't Shut Down

If you shut down and stop communicating, resentment grows and problems fester.

Don't Minimise Your Feelings

"Maybe I'm wrong to feel hurt" → This teaches them that defensiveness works. Don't do this.

Don't Keep Trying the Same Approach

If your gentle feedback triggers defensiveness, a harsher approach won't help. You need a different strategy.

What TO Do

Step 1: Pick Your Timing and Tone Carefully

  • When they're calm (not stressed, tired, or already upset)
  • Privately (not in front of others)
  • Gently (not harshly, but not so soft you're not being clear)
  • From a place of love ("I love you and need to share something")

Step 2: Use "I" Statements

Instead of: "You hurt me"
Try: "I felt hurt when X happened"

Instead of: "You're defensive"
Try: "I notice it's hard for us to talk about certain things"

Step 3: Ask Permission

"Can I share something that's been on my mind?" gives them a moment to prepare, reducing defensiveness.

Step 4: Focus on One Thing

Not: "You always do X, Y, and Z"
But: "I want to talk about what happened yesterday"

Step 5: Invite Dialogue, Don't Lecture

"What do you think about that?" vs. "Here's everything you need to change"

Step 6: Validate Their Experience

Even if you disagree, acknowledge their perspective: "I understand that's how you saw it."

Step 7: Set a Boundary if Necessary

If they get defensive anyway:

"I want to have this conversation, but I need us both to be able to listen without attacking each other. Can we try again?"

If they refuse:

"I care about you, but I can't keep having conversations where I can't be honest. I need us to work on this together, or I'm going to feel very alone in this relationship."

The Deeper Issue

Defensive behaviour in relationships often points to low ego awareness and fragile ego strength.

Your partner might not even realise they're being defensive. From their perspective, they're just responding to your attack.

This is why couples therapy is valuable. A therapist can help both of you see patterns you can't see on your own.

Recommended Reading

Key Takeaway

Defensive behaviour is almost always about their fear, not your fault. Understanding this helps you respond with compassion instead of defensiveness of your own.

But compassion doesn't mean accepting endless defensiveness. You can be kind and still have boundaries about what you will and won't accept.

Related Articles:

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← back to articles
↑ top